Archive and Search
Login
« The Winery Dogs Release 'Captain Love' Video | Main | Dokken Classic Lineup Reunites... In Japan »
Friday
May272016

Belated RIP Nick Menza: 1964-201

Today's post is from our friend HIM. 


This is old news that needs a hearing. Nick Menza, best known for his work during the most commercially popular period in Megadeth’s history, passed away this past Saturday (May 21). He died doing that thing that rockers—the Lemmys of the music world—claim they want to do: playing.

That he was playing in OHM, alongside another former member of Megadeth, Chris Poland, matters only in terms of connective dots. But it points to a truth: Menza had been part of a band that featured a lot of incredible musicians.
 
It might seem off-putting to say this, but I will: I always enjoyed Gary “Gar” Samuelson’s drumming more.  Not being a musician myself, I can attribute that to the fact that Gar was the drummer on the albums that signaled Mustaine’s phoenix-like rise from the ash-heap of a situation he created in Metallica. Or the fact that he reminded me of, in some odd way, Bill Ward.
 
But what had I been listening to in recent weeks? Hidden Treasures. And what song always caught my attention? “99 Ways to Die”:
 


 

From the Beavis & Butthead movie no less. And what keeps me listening to that song? Those damn drums. So what I am saying is this: I love Gar, but I can’t stop listening to Menza. And the list of Megadeth songs that I consistently listen to these days trace more to him than to his predecessor. So perhaps I am a sucker for origins even if I have always been a Megadeth fan. While I resisted Megadeth’s rise, feeling like they were leaving Vic Rattlehead behind for a more ‘Tallica-like polish, I still can’t get the Menza (not Friedman, because it was Mustaine that mattered to me) out of my head.
 
And you want to see a man in his element, some 26 years ago, with the other components of Megadeth a distant sound in the background? Try this:
 


 

Again, I am no musician. But at approx. 1:50, Menza is amazing. And, throughout it all, you see something else: a smile. Slightly mischievous. But a smile that signals an artist who loves what he does. And, sadly or happily, died doing that very same thing not more than a week ago.
 
People on other sites can question Mustaine’s reactions to his death. I don’t. They can also bag on Megadeth itself, making that the story. I won’t. They can even question the actions that led him to being dropped and also led him to not being a part of Megadeth today. Not my place. What we can’t question is this: Nick Menza died of a heart attack, while playing music, in front of fans. We also can’t question the fact—not opinion, mind you—that Menza added something to music that will last long past his sad death.
 
Rest in Peace, Menza. Fans of metal, no less fans of music, mourn your passing.

 

Reader Comments (9)

I honestly didn't know much about him other than yes, he played with Megadeth at one point.

But I was saddened to learn of his passing at such a very young age. Makes you realize how precious life really is. Scary how it can all be gone in the blink of an eye.

Condolences to his loved ones. RIP.
May 27, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterRita
I mentioned Nick 5 days ago. Its sad unless youre popular no one cares. At least the real metal websites that knew his talent and what a great person he was showed him their respect. How is it they already determined it was natural causes that killed him and yet they havent said anything about a junkie named prince and its been over a month.

Put a red rose on my grave
May 27, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterBadland
Hopefully, Badland, you will consider my post another sign of respect (and I did notice your post, even as I was already crafting mine).

I think it is a pretty simple question re: Menza vs. Prince: the tox report signaled that there was nothing in Menza's system that would warrant or trigger further testing beyond COD. With Prince, the circumstance (to my mind, sadly, as I thought he was a great talent) warranted a much more expansive toxicology write up, etc. I also read that the criminal investigation surrounding his (Prince's) death could also delay COD being released. Several other sites have written up far more cogent explanations of the situation.

Either way, Menza was part of a band I loved. His contributions were a gift. And this is a loss to his family, friends, and fans.
May 28, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterHim
Way to keep it tacky, Gary. Sorry to break it to ya but musically speaking, Prince>>>Menza and it's not even close.
May 28, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterBkallday
Sorry, that was for Badlands.
May 28, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterBkallday
R.I.P. Menza. A helluva drummer for a helluva band. Far better than jacka*s extraordinaire Lars Ulrich or any of the others in The (So-Called) Big 4.
May 29, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterMetalboy!
Menza was a terrific drummer during a period for Megadeth when they scaled the pinnacle of thrash metal and then transioned into a great straight heavy metal (Countdown to Extinction) to then transition again to a great mostly-hard rock band (with elements of metal incorporated). I feel that as much as Rust in Peace gets regulalry placed in top ten (often higher) lists of greatest metal albums of all time, with CTE usually making such lists when they are expanded (top 50, top 100?), Youthanasia does not get enough love for the GREAT hard rock/metal album it is. Pretty amazing three album stretch for that band. The last album Menza played on, Cryptic Writings, suffers a bit from a lack of focus and not feeling as cohesive ( it tries to be a bit more melodic and harder at the same time) but is still a pretty good record (Trust, Secret Place, She-Wolf, Disintegrators, FFF, Vortex) and Menza's drumming was a significant factor in making those four albums great. Thanks for this post.
May 30, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterForge
Awesome post, Forge. Post more often. You offer a great snapshot of the Menza era.

Sites like this need that sort of passionate detail.
May 30, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterHim
Forge, yes, thank you for filling in the blanks for me as I am only a casual listener compared to yourself, HIM and others commenting here, yet only respect them as far as The Big Four. The rest of them don't do a thing for me. It is only Megadeth who I hold in high regard amongst them.

Please continue to comment as you seem to be a wealth of knowledge about Metal and have a real knack for clearly defining it's nuances, something rarely so well articulated here, myself included.
June 2, 2016 | Unregistered CommenterMetalboy!

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.